Not all carbohydrates are created equal - some actually have a negative impact on climate. So which carbohydrates are bad for the environment?
Yes, you read that right. Carbs can be bad for the climate. Which ones though?
Rice cultivation, like other carbohydrates, causes soil and water pollution because of pesticide and fertiliser use. All carbohydrates require the input of energy and raw materials (like fuel and fertilisers) which are responsible for nitrous oxide and carbon dioxide emissions. Nevertheless, rice cultivation is responsible for 10-13% of worldwide methane emissions (1). Indeed, rice is produced by flooding the field. In the paddy fields methanotrophs, soil microorganisms, produce methane, increasing the impact of rice on global warming. All these factors make rice the worst carbohydrate in terms of the climate.
Organic rice has a higher carbon footprint than conventional rice. Per hectare, organic rice has lower emissions for methane and nitrous oxide. However, due to the lower grain yield, the emissions of methane per kg of paddy rice increases leading to a higher impact on the climate. Nevertheless, the avoided use of pesticides has positive impacts on biodiversity.
Rice has a high carbon footprint of about 2.55 kg CO2e/kg (2), compared to potatoes which has an average value of 0.2 kg CO2e/kg (3) and pasta which has an average value of 0.79 kg of CO2e/kg (4).
Wheat releases zero methane emissions. So the carbon footprint of pasta is lower than rice, even if pasta is an industrial product and undergoes a processing step. In fact, wheat milling and pasta manufacturing accounts for only 35% of the total carbon footprint of pasta (5).
When it comes to the best carbohydrate in the world, potatoes are great! They are low in calories, rich in nutrients (vitamin B and C, potassium), low in fat and they have a very low carbon footprint. Potato production is characterised by high yields and relatively low fertiliser amounts. However, the potato ranks third behind rice and wheat as food consumed, since consumption of fresh potatoes has declined while processed products (like pasta) have increased in popularity (6).
Another thing that we can do to reduce our climate impact besides selecting the type of carb, is to cook sustainably! Did you know that the cooking phase adds between 0.76 and 2.21 kg CO2e/kg depending on if the stove is gas or electric? A study reveals (7), utilising the so-called passive cooking method saves up to 80% of greenhouse gas emissions while cooking.
Pasta cooking time can be divided in two parts: the time needed to boil water and the one necessary to cook pasta. Usually, after boiling water, pasta is cooked by keeping the heat on for the entire suggested cooking time, e.g. for 10 minutes (active cooking). However, pasta can be cooked in a more efficient way by keeping the heat on only for the first 2 minutes of cooking and then, for the remaining suggested time, the heat can be turned off while keeping the lid on the pot (passive cooking).
Considering the cooking process of a 10-minutes-cooking 80g portion of pasta, cooked with gas and electric stoves, these are the possible savings:
Cook the pasta until it is ‘al dente’ (it doesn’t need to be cooked for longer than this according to our in-house Italian scientist!). Just remember to stir from time to time and the organoleptic properties of your pasta will remain unaltered!
The method applies to rice as well. At Klimato we love our experiments!
Upland rice has lower emissions as it is cultivated mainly in Asia at high altitudes without submersion and grown under a reduced water regime. Conventionally farmed rice currently requires a huge amount of water, 5m3 to be precise (8). The production method of Upland rice at the minute is on a small scale but if this was to become the mainstream production method, then this may save considerable amounts of water, by 30%, especially when furrow irrigation is used (9). It also reduces the climate impact of rice production since the fields are no longer flooded by up to 50% (10).
As consumers we play a big role with our choices. The rice industry could become more and more efficient in the future, but the natural processes are difficult to change, thus, rice will always be more impactful than pasta and potatoes. It is up to us to reduce the demand for rice.
Consider a rice risotto with buckwheat “risotto” (with confit tomatoes it’s delicious) or try other grains like sorghum or millet. Grains emit around 0.50 kg CO2e/kg (11), while rice is 2.55 kg CO2e/kg. You save up to 80% of carbon emissions! Alternatively, add lentils to your curry rather than serving it with rice.
You know what to do? Yes! Share this article with friends and family to spread the truth on carbs!
This article has been reposted from its original publication in Vegan Food & Living magazine. To read the original article click here.
May 25, 2023
Reduce your carbon footprint with Klimato's guide to climate-friendly food choices. Discover impacts of meat, dairy, fish, carbs, and more!
February 7, 2023
The results for 2022 are in! We are extremely proud of everything we have accomplished together with our amazing customers to continue reducing emissions from food.